Maurizio – Omnologos

Where no subject is left unturned

The Moral Equivalence of Hamas and Israel (and us)

with 4 comments

Another day, another series of reports on tens of dead, dying and injured people in Israel and the Palestinian territories.

I’ll leave the sorting out of who’s to blame to anybody wishing to waste their time.

Sure, there are more victims on the Palestinian side than on the Israeli, indicating an overwhelmingly disproportionate response as if the value of human life really depended on nationality (a consideration unfathomably shared by the Palestinian leadership too: prisoners exchange usually involve a handful of Israelis to tens of Palestinians).

On the other hand what purpose can it be in the launching of aimless rockets by Hamas, randomly towards civilians? Apart, that is, from killing if not terrorizing them on purpose, because they are civilians: as if that has ever won anybody’s war.

The height of mutual stupidity is that people in charge on the two sides are determined to brutalize each other. At the same time, retaliation after retaliation, they have kind of abdicated all hopes of recovering their own humanity…to the sudden appearance of virtuous behavior in the other camp.

It’s fairly obvious that whatever the causes of their madness, they are all directly responsible for untold miseries that will befall on their own children.

=========

What should be done to bring peace to Israeli and Palestinians alike? It’s more than obvious, it’s actually boring. Stop wishing the others could go away. Realize the land is for the two of them, and for the rest of humanity as well. Decouple Israel from the messianic undertones, by getting it into the European Union.

But that doesn’t look like in anybody’s interest. The main hope is that the situation has worsened since the quasi-agreement with President Clinton in 2000, because when everybody knows peace is tantalizingly near, everybody rushes to settle the last scores.

=========

But that’s still too easy an analysis.  

Who else is brutalizing civilians in the futile attempt of getting a military and thus a political advantage in a never-ending war, worsened exactly because and by that brutalization?

It’s us from NATO.

The civilian victims are in Afghanistan, nowadays, and likely but less evidently in Iraq.

And it’s no novelty. Leaving aside the famously useless killings of tens of thousands in Dresden during World War II, just fifty years ago the French Government tried almost casually to defend the bloody bombing of a Tunisian border village, in the Algerian war.

Despite our illusions, things have not changed since. We are still eliminating fellow human beings without much of a thought. Here’s NATO proudly using American and European taxpayers’ money to kill road building workers. Never, or almost never, big news in our media.

=========

It is high time we leave aside idle discussions about other peoples’ business to mind about our own idiocy.

Written by omnologos

2008/Mar/02 at 22:25:00

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Please — regarding this post, please see the following:

    http://www.ifamericansknew.org/

    http://rafahtoday.org/

    http://www.al-bushra.org/

    An occupied people — despair — loss of hope — cruel treatment — without means of protection unless we who know what is happening, do something.

    Jeanne

    2008/Mar/03 at 02:11:18

  2. Please, no more linking of frankly propaganda sites, particularly those that demonize Israel while calling indiscriminate launching of missiles, mortars and suicide bombers “resistance to the occupation.”

    joelsk44039

    2008/Mar/03 at 11:29:32

  3. There is a very topical article in the latest “Diary” of the London Review of Books.

    Note that Yonatan Mendel talks about Israeli journalism. For me, it describes the situation for much of “Western” media organization (and people).

    omnologos

    2008/Mar/03 at 22:24:20

  4. It is so sad reading this. Almost to the point of insanity reading this. I mean — one could go insane trying to fathom why entire nations swallow these semantics so obvious to others… .

    Jeanne

    2008/Mar/11 at 05:58:37


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: