Maurizio – Omnologos

Where no subject is left unturned

No War Without the Draft

with 6 comments

The droning on of the Iraq war is a tragedy of middle-class pacifism

The draft, the forced conscription especially of men in their late teens and early twenties forcefully sent off to learn how to behave in a war, has been as unpopular in Western Europe and the USA in the last 30 years as a fact of life since the days of the French Revolution.

But now, its end has paradoxically brought about a situation where wars can be fought without much care for the approval by the people, and hence without real concern for using military power and personnel wisely and efficiently.

The turning point may have been Vietnam, another war of wastefully managed people and equipment. At the time, relatively well-off college and university American students vehemently protested, and many youths got dispatched to premature deaths also because of their families’ lack of economic and political links to find a way around the “call to arms”

Earlier efforts had seen far fewer troubles. The minority today’s American political leaders served in Vietnam, whilst the majority of their fathers fought world-conquering Germany and Japan up, close and personal.

Fast forward to 2007. The draft is no longer, in America since 1973. All soldiers are volunteers. But whilst the Iraqi conflict is going nowhere, popular protests are insignificant, with no danger of a re-run of the killings at Kent State (1970) or the riots at the Chicago Democratic Convention of 1968.

In one sense, the droning on of the Iraq war is a tragedy of middle-class pacifism. Even if many people may be unsure, unhappy and/or against the war, they do not march down the streets: because the conflict does not impact the daily lives of most people “back home” (in the USA, but also in the UK),

On the other hand, all those that opted for a military career, perhaps during the Clinton years, have found themselves facing the prospect of multiple trips to Iraq, literally at great danger of loss of life and limb (and their mind, too).

Whatever their original “lifestyle choice” for the military, surely after the second tour of duty the Nation is unfairly taking advantage of them? Either the war is important and all resources should be poured into getting it won, (especially after years and years); or it is not, and so every life lost there, including those of volunteer soldiers, is a tragic waste.

Those volunteers have dedicated their lives to fight for the USA. This does not mean the USA have a right to treat them as consumables: just like even if policemen and medics, having voluntarily joined their professions, are ready to give their lives to patrol the street or fight infectious diseases, still the State does not have a right to misuse them.

And yet that is what is happening in the Iraq war, where 10 dead a week is treated as “good news”; pictures of returning body bags are forbidden; veterans are not given appropriate treatment; and now somebody is suggesting monthly group commemorations, instead of proper salutes to each of the fallen.

With the disappearance of the draft it’s as if wars, always too serious to be left to generals, have been abandoned to politicians.

After all, Presidents, Senators and Representatives live off votes. As so, if votes do not depend on the care reserved to military personnel including casualties, there is no democratic control on wars: the Republic may have its President, but the Armed Forces risk being at the mercy of a Tyrant King with the same title.

That is a tragedy in itself. With freely elected governments and parliaments, and fairly independent judiciary, modern democracies have been fantastically good at avoiding warring each other, whilst in the XX century tens of millions have died in armed conflict. Such a miraculous result has surely something to do with the checks-and-balances of the 1787 American Constitution, whence most others derive. Unpopular and/or incompetent leaders can be voted off the power chair, and delinquent ones can be brought in front of the Law.

The remedy, as in many cases, is in the middle. Don’t just reintroduce universal draft. Don’t just leave conflicts to “professionals” with the result that intolerable amounts of them will die fruitlessly whilst wars will drag on as long as money is still available.

Simply, reintroduce the draft temporarily and only _in case of_ war. And so ultimately empower the voters, that will have to face the real issues, and decide if the Nation has the stomach to start or join the fight.

If it has not, and the citizens refuse the draft, then there is no point in going to war anyway. If instead the Nation agrees it’s time to go to war then, the whole draft-risking electorate will have all the reasons to closely follow the conflict, and get their opinions fully heard: thereby re-establishing the full checks and balances of a healthy democracy.

And who knows, perhaps there will be no more escape clauses for former enthusiasts later to claim they never really believed in the war.

Written by omnologos

2007/Aug/12 at 19:40:41

Posted in Democracy, Ethics, Humanity, USA

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I have heard it said that conscripted fighters try harder to survive, with related improvements in the force.

    However, there are a couple reasons why there should not be a draft. The first has to do with freedom; it is a strange irony to take a way freedom to fight for our freedoms. The second is a measure of war. If men do not rise up to defend the nation, then there was not a good reason for the war.


    2007/Aug/13 at 01:56:14

  2. Scott: on the other hand, if the Nation democratically decides to fight a war…

    Your proposal could be modified into some kind of rule: “if a war is started, and by 6 months into it less than 15% of the eligible fighting force volunteers, the war must be terminated due to apparent lack of public support”


    2007/Aug/13 at 08:15:28

  3. The draft did not stop the Korean and Vietnam wars. It will not stop the Iraq war.That’s Rangel’s illusion. The problem is our foreign policy, which since the end of WWII invites endless wars, and more body bags and crippled vets.

    Another draft would be a horrible blunder and a serious violation of personal liberty.

    By the way, I served in the Army.

    Murray Polner

    2007/Aug/13 at 13:08:48

  4. Murray

    do you see the Iraq war ever ending? No draft, no protests, no reason to leave.


    2007/Aug/13 at 13:55:44

  5. Sadly, it will only end as did the Vietnam War:When the overwhelming majority of corporate and political centrists decide they’ve had enough. That, of course, assumes (a hell of an assumption) that the incompetent and bellicose blunderers now in authority in DC don’t attack Iran, consequences be damned.

    Therefore, to answer your question with another question:”Do you see the VN war ever ending”?

    Since there will not be a draft
    while the Iraq War drags on endlessly, the
    only hope for ending this entirely unnecessary war is to keep pressuring your politicians and writing to your local papers and to blogs such as yours. Vox Populi.

    Murray Polner

    2007/Aug/19 at 14:43:31

  6. Murray,

    I disagree that the draft didn’t stop Vietnam.

    The institution of the Lottery Draft system meant that the well to do in this country were no longer able to hide their children in the Reserve and the National Guard. Once that happened, the conclusion was quickly reached that the costs outweighed the benefits of continuing.

    A lottery draft harnesses two basic human emotions. 1. Money Talks and BS Walks. 2. Where your heart is, so is your treasure.

    Reinstitute the lottery draft and watch how quickly we come to our senses and how many sacred cows come up on the negotiating table. Not only will we find a solution for Iraq, but energy independence will become more than something we talk about.

    See discussion at

    Larry Bradley

    2007/Sep/13 at 03:34:52

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: